Faith RethinkFaith RethinkFaith RethinkFaith Rethink
  • About Peter
    • About Peter’s Blog
  • Blog
    • Follow
  • Media
  • Store
  • Contact

What is lost by rewriting our national narrative without the voices of the vulnerable?

    Home American history What is lost by rewriting our national narrative without the voices of the vulnerable?
    NextPrevious

    What is lost by rewriting our national narrative without the voices of the vulnerable?

    By Peter Watts | American history | 0 comment | 25 July, 2019 | 6

    Silencing the vulnerable

    For those who are listening and attentive to the world around us, it’s often the loudest voices that get heard the most. Unfortunately, it seems, the louder you get and the more obnoxious you are can even get you elected president. Being loud has it’s place, but not when it neglects and silences the voices of the vulnerable in society.

    Voices like the powerless, the outsider, the unprivileged, and the underpaid.

    As a teacher of history, it’s important to me that students nurture their human sensitivities to hear the voices of the vulnerable. Both in our nation’s history and in current affairs. To not hear them is not only detrimental to them, but to the future generations they impact. When we don’t include their voices in our collective identity and story, we create a narrative of our nation that is only partially true.

    Because the truth is uncomfortable, isn’t it? The truth is not easy to swallow. The truth forces us to stop and think. The truth forces us to think about what we are doing and why we are doing it. And how what we are doing and why we are doing it affects others around us.

    It forces us to recognize that what we do in this world is never truly in isolation. A person’s isolation impacts people. Because where you could of or should of showed up, you didn’t. You let it go. You ignored.

    But “ignorance is” not “bliss.” Ignorance is another way of saying “I’m perfectly fine living my life as is and I don’t need to be uncomfortable with someone else’s problems.”

    Because when we begin to look at and give dignity to what is uncomfortable, we may need to make changes in our lives.

    Remembering our national heritage

    History is often told through the eyes of the conqueror. Through the wealthiest and most powerful in society. Such has been true in the telling of our own country’s history at various points in the past and at various locations around the nation. Doing so has created the faulty assumption of American exceptionalism, which as it turns out is a kind of nationalistic prejudice over and against all other nations and people groups from those nations.

    But the tide is changing.

    History texts are now being written to include the voices of the vulnerable. The conquered, not just the conquerors. The powerless, not just the powerful. The outsider, not just the insider. Whole movements over the last fifty years have made space for their voices to be heard. To affirm their God-given dignity and value.

    Unfortunately, however, not everyone wants to hear the voices of the vulnerable. Ironically many of those who refuse to listen to the vulnerable come from a family lineage of those who were once vulnerable. Who were once outsiders looking in.

    They have only forgotten it or perhaps ignored it.

    They ignore their ancestral roots and the roots of our great nation. And their ignorance has grown to the point that the story they tell themselves and their children is much different than that of what actually happened. It’s a pretend story without ethical conflicts. Without displacement and prejudice and economic disparity. A story that ignores those who make their lives, well…less comfortable.

    They have told this false narrative long enough that they now believe it.

    But that story–the made up one–erases much of our nation’s history, complexity, problems and pain.

    The people of this great nation deserve better than that.

    The Native American population deserves better than that.

    Migrants and their families (some of which are yours) who have come to the US since the early years deserve better than that.

    Because where we come from and how we got here matters.

    Don’t squander the telling of our history with false narratives.

    Be brave and listen to the voices of the vulnerable.

    And remember where you came from.

     

    In Summary:

    “So what’s this blog post about Peter?” you may be asking. 

    Glad you asked. It’s about not excusing injustice. It’s about learning to listen to others. It’s about putting yourself in someone else’s shoes. It’s about entering into other’s brokenness. It’s about learning to be human with yourself and with others. It’s about putting a stop to your ignorance. It’s about making a difference in the lives of others. And it’s about being a thoughtful reader of history. It’s about letting the uncomfortable story of our great nation sink in, inform and transform the way you live. That is what this post is about.

     

    For some history texts and book recommendations, click on the following links:

     

     

    immigrants, insider, least of these, nation of immigrants, national narrative, outsider, underpaid, unprivileged, US History

    Peter Watts

    More posts by Peter Watts

    Related Post

    • 5 Lingering Questions from Year Three of the Pandemic

      By Peter Watts | 0 comment

      Pandemic fatigue It’s been just over two years since the novel coronavirus entered our world and nation. Many of us had hoped and assumed that 2021 would be the final year of the pandemic, butRead more

    • 2021

      2021: A year in review

      By Peter Watts | 0 comment

      2021 was supposed to be completely different from 2020. Most people had hoped that once midnight struck on New Years Eve of 2020, we could turn the page on a year of incredible trauma, andRead more

    • Picture of the Novel Coronavirus

      20 Facts about COVID-19

      By Peter Watts | 2 comments

      I hope the following post helps clarify important facts and details that have often been misunderstood about the Coronavirus pandemic. Please utilize this information and the sources cited in conversations with your own family, friendsRead more

    • Nurse in a hospital

      Covid-19 Pandemic: How we got here and how to get out

      By Peter Watts | 0 comment

      Questions about the pandemic It’s been nearly two years (at the time of this writing) since our world was plunged into the coronavirus pandemic. Two years. The close of 2020 was supposed to mark theRead more

    • The Temple Mount in Jerusalem

      Christian Zionism misses the entire point of Jesus’ mission: A reflection on Jewish and Arab Palestinian History

      By Peter Watts | 2 comments

      The author of this blog reflection acknowledges that the wars and conflicts in the Middle East in general and in Palestine in particular are complicated, often nuanced, with varying interpretations within both the Jewish IsraeliRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    Recent Posts

    • A Hanukkah Story: Discovering it’s Meaning, Beauty & History
    • Questions and answers about the atonement
    • Cruciform atonement: How the death of Jesus on a Roman cross changes everything
    • 7 Bible stories you think you know but don’t
    • Reengaging with the Bible’s Biggest Themes

    Archives

    • December 2022
    • June 2022
    • January 2022
    • December 2021
    • November 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • March 2021
    • February 2021
    • January 2021
    • December 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    • September 2019
    • August 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
    • May 2019
    • April 2019
    • February 2019
    • November 2018
    • September 2018

    Categories

    • American history
    • Asking questions
    • Authentic Christianity
    • Bible
    • Biblical inerrancy
    • Biblical violence
    • Christian hope
    • Escapist theologies
    • Evangelicalism
    • Evolving faith
    • Following Jesus
    • Forgiveness
    • God in the face of Jesus
    • God in the questions
    • God who risks
    • Jesus
    • Learning and growing
    • New humanity
    • Open theism
    • Power & authority
    • Religious tolerance
    • Risk theology
    • Roman crucifixion
    • Sacrifice
    • Self-made project
    • Servant project
    • Spiritual journey
    • Stories
    • Uncategorized

    Menu

    • About Peter
    • Blog
    • Media
    • Store
    • Contact

    Recent Posts

    • A Hanukkah Story: Discovering it’s Meaning, Beauty & History

      Imagine you are a Hebrew living in the 2nd century BCE in

      25 December, 2022

    Search

    Copyright 2020 Peter E. Watts | Faith Rethink LLC | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
    • About Peter
    • About Peter’s Blog
    • Blog
    • Checkout
    • Contact Peter
    • Follow
    • Media
    • Newest Blog Post
    • Older Posts
    • Order Confirmation
    • Order Failed
    • Privacy Policy
    • Speaking
    • Store
    • Home
    Faith Rethink